New Rules For Blog Reviewers

The new FTC guidelines about bloggers and tweeters who recommend books would be funny if it didn’t raise the possibility of a lot of confusion and inadvertent law-breaking. According to the new rules, bloggers who review free copies of books they’ve been given by an author or publisher must disclose the book as merchandise received. If publishers send free review copies to bloggers, either directly or through a middleman, they must disclose the distribution and monitor the subsequent conduct of the “endorsers” who received them.

The FTC isn’t claiming these new guidelines are laws, they’re calling them “guides.” However, they can fine a violator of the new guidelines as much as $11,000 per infraction. They offer bloggers wiggle-room by saying that if reviewers donate the free copy after reviewing it, they don’t have to disclose they ever got it, since it doesn’t represent “lasting compensation.” But many free review copies end up on eBay, so the sales could become a sticky issue.

The whole thing is pretty silly, and probably completely unenforceable. I don’t get free review copies of books, but if a friend passes along a book to me and I like it so much that I write a recommendation on my blog, I could theoretically get in trouble with the FTC if I don’t make sure that I pass the book along to somebody else. Books flow through my hands pretty regularly, so I probably don’t run much chance of being busted for nondisclosure of a free book I’ve reviewed. But if the guidelines are enforced, online reviewers may find themselves having to keep records and account for the source and final disposition of books they recommend.

The FTC doesn’t have enough staff to monitor every blogger and tweeter who recommends a book, so the whole thing will probably fall into a crack and be forgotten. But it raises some interesting issues. What’s your take on the idea of bloggers who review books having to report free copies as compensation?


2 thoughts on “New Rules For Blog Reviewers

  1. That’s just plain crazy! Corporation and banking execs and investment brokers have looted our country’s finances, health insurance execs make millions denying health care — and we are going to go after people who get free review copies of books? I used to love to watch _Twilight Zone_, but I don’t want to live there.

  2. Amen, Mary! I’m currently reading Margaret Atwood’s latest — I paid for it — and like her other dystopic novels, it seems creepily true of where we’re headed if we don’t get a grip on what is and what is not important in life. Even Rod Serling wouldn’t have imagined some of our silliness.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s